Back To Latest Articles

How have past Sargassum blooms affected hotel performance?

The upcoming summer travel season is an especially important one for the Caribbean and Mexico hotel industries. While performance recovery has ramped up as 2022 has progressed, this summer will be the first of the pandemic-era with travel restrictions lifted in many of the Caribbean’s tourism source markets as well as in key islands in the region. Mexico has been further along in recovery, which has expectations for the summer even higher.

However, in addition to challenges that still exist from the pandemic, hoteliers may face additional headwinds from high levels of Sargassum seaweed blooms. In addition to environmental concerns, Sargassum presents an issue for destinations because its unpleasant smell and presence can discourage beachgoing tourists.

According to a recent bulletin from the University of South Florida Optical Oceanography Lab, the Caribbean Sea, the Gulf of Mexico, and the Central West Atlantic region saw historical April levels of Sargassum with increases expected through July.

To help Caribbean and Mexico hotel industry stakeholders understand the potential impact from Sargassum blooms, we pulled key points from a previous STR analysis focused on performance in the Caribbean. Additional performance variables at the time of the last major Sargassum bloom make it difficult to isolate the potential impact in Mexico.

Impact in 2018 and 2019

Caribbean hotel occupancy dipped year over year during the seaweed blooms of 2018 and 2019. For context, however, the declines were not nearly as significant as those observed during hurricanes. For example, the region observed a double-digit drop in occupancy in September 2017 due to Hurricane Irma and then a 9% drop in 2018 October as a result of Hurricane Michael.

In terms of average daily rate (ADR), hotelier pricing power remained strong despite occupancy fluctuations amid Sargassum blooms. 

From the previous analysis, Barbados and the Cayman Islands were good examples of the performance dichotomy between areas affected and unaffected by Sargussum.

Hotels located in Barbados unaffected by Sargassum experienced a year-over-year increase in RevPAR (+3%) in the January-July year-to-date period (2018), whereas hotels located in the affected region reported drops in occupancy (-4.7%) and RevPAR (-4.4%).

Image
Hotel Performance in Sargassum Affected and Unaffected Regions in Barbados, YTD July 2018

According to Sargassum Monitoring, Grand Cayman Sargassum blooms were most prevalent in the southern areas of the island. Most hotels on the island are high-end.

Image
Cayman Islands Unaffected Area 12 MMA RevPAR% Change, January - July 2018
Image
Grand Cayman Hotels Unaffected by Sargassum

Current hotel performance landscape

A look at preliminary data from April 2022 showed Caribbean hotel occupancy at 66%, which was roughly 6% below the pre-pandemic comparable from April 2019. ADR (US$326), on the other hand, was 20% higher. In Mexico, occupancy was 64%, up 1.2% from 2019, while ADR was MXN3,186 (+26.1% from 2019.) In the Cancun market, occupancy was 74% (+10%) with an ADR of MXN5,396 (+75%).

Future analysis

STR will continue to monitor performance through summer 2022 and report on any impact from Sargassum blooms as appropriate.